You are here: Home › Stressors › Resource & Land Use › Development of Polyculture Systems for the Production of Juvenile Reef Fishes Suitable for Stock Enhancement
Development of Polyculture Systems for the Production of Juvenile Reef Fishes Suitable for Stock Enhancement
Note: missing images, not in right format
Project Goals
The project, Development of Polyculture Systems for the Production of
Juvenile Reef Fishes Suitable for Stock Enhancement, accomplished its
primary goal of testing an enriched culture environment for the production
of juvenile fish behaviorally suitable for the restoration of marine
fish stocks. This
involved development of polyculture systems for marine fish and habitat forming
species, specifically seagrass and oysters, and testing the hypothesis that
fish reared in polyculture were behaviorally better adapted for release in
the wild than fish reared in conventional monoculture.
1) The
construction of a new type of experimental facility at the CCFHR, a greenhouse
for the polyculture of plants and animals.
Major milestones included:
- Student training through the development of new cultured fishes stocks and their experimental evaluation.
- Pilot scale replicated rearing trials with representative species of two dominant reef fish families (Pigfish, Orthopristis chrysoptera, Linnaeus, family Haemulidae and Black sea bass, Centropristis striata, Linnaeus, family Serranidae). Trials compared growth and survival of fishes reared in conventional monoculture and in polyculture with associated habitat species. The execution and analysis of experiments comparing behavioral characteristics of juvenile grunts and sea bass reared in monoculture and polyculture systems.
Project Background
Reef fish stocks are generally in poor condition throughout US waters (NMFS 1999) and stocks of some grouper species ( Nassau grouper, Goliath grouper) are so low that their harvest is prohibited in US waters by law. Ault et al. (2001) concluded that the fishing mortality rate for groupers in the Tortugas region was 2 to 10 times the exploitation level that would achieve Maximum Sustainable Yield (MSY). Unfortunately over fishing is not limited to groupers and “serial over fishing”, where the largest species are removed first followed by smaller, less desirable species (Ault et al, 1998), has proceeded to the extent that even some grunt populations are chronically over fished. Although increased fishery regulation and the creation of marine protected areas (MPA) should alleviate chronic over fishing of many stocks, particular species and particular regions may be slow to respond to conventional management techniques.
One management alternative is the stocking of hatchery reared juveniles. It is important to distinguish such cases into those where intensive stock enhancement programs may be effective and those where a smaller scale but focused effort seems more likely to succeed. Intensive stock enhancement generally applies to widely distributed stocks of particular economic and cultural importance such as red drum and striped bass, in the US, and Japanese flounder and red sea bream in Japan. The importance of such stocks has insured the development of systems that can support massive stocking programs and the ability to saturate systems with hatchery reared juveniles stocked primarily to enhance the fishery. In contrast, for stocks of smaller size and limited geographic range that have been overexploited to the extent that the fishery is no longer viable, systems for mass production of juveniles are unlikely to have been developed and availability of brood fish may be limiting. In such cases, an alternative goal is to reestablish an adult group of sufficient size and in a suitable location to allow natural reproduction and transport processes to allow or speed the recovery of the species throughout the system. In such a situation a more focused effort is required and the emphasis shifted from the quantity of fish stocked to their genetic variability, retention in the system and survival through the reproductive stage. Of critical importance to this type of restoration program is the behavioral and physiological quality of stocked fish as a variety of studies have demonstrated that cultured fish exhibit behavioral deficits linked to low survival after stocking (Brown and Laland, 2001).
It is with this situation in mind that we conducted polyculture studies of reef fish species and depending on their juvenile habitat association, oysters or sea grass. Comparative studies of fish monoculture and fish/habitat species polyculture were conducted with two fish species from families that play dominate roles in coral reef systems. The schooling grunts (represented by the pig fish, Orthopristis chrysoptera, Linnaeus, family Haemulidae), can dominate reef fish communities in terms of biomass and are considered of great ecological and commercial importance (Gaut and Munro, 1983). The groupers (represented by the black sea bass, Centropristis striata, Linnaeus, family Serranidae), are large territorial piscivores and are considered apex predators within the reef fish community.
Experimental System
The facility in which these studies were conducted was constructed from the ground up with funds provided by National Sea Grant through the Office of Applied Research. The system was designed to integrate with the existing mariculture experimental system at CCFHR and consisted of two buildings, the greenhouse that housed the experimental culture tanks and the water conditioning building (Fig. 1).
Figure 1. Schematic diagram of greenhouse culture facility and recirculating and conditioning system.
Water is conditioned in a recirculating system that includes mechanical and biological filtration and temperature control. The 80 m² greenhouse (Van Wingerden Greenhouse Co.) was constructed on a raised concrete pad poured to provide three floor gutters to allow the outflow of re-circulated water to a return sump tank or to our system outfall. Eight culture tanks constructed from concrete burial vaults were set on the pad and supplied with re-circulated water and aeration. The addition of this system to the CCFHR mariculture facility significantly expanded capabilities to include the culture of plants under controlled conditions.
Training
The training aspect of this project was accomplished through an agreement with the Aquaculture Technology Program of Carteret Community College to provide internships for undergraduate students and by the participation of an Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education (ORISE) fellow, James Morris. In addition, students from the University of North Carolina at Wilmington and Smith College participated as interns. Students received hands on training in various aspects of aquaculture while providing critical labor towards accomplishing the goals of the project. James Morris received extensive training in the development of hatchery stocks, systems and experimental design. He continues to work at the Laboratory where he is now responsible for operation of the seawater system and studies the invasive Lionfish (Pterois volitans) and red porgy (Pagrus pagrus). The greenhouse facility has and continues to provide various teaching opportunities with local universities and colleges including class tours and demonstrations for students from Elizabeth City State University, East Carolina University, and Carteret Community College Aquaculture Technology program.
Project Results and Discussion
Comparative studies with these behaviorally distinct species demonstrate that polyculture produces fish that perform significantly better than monoculture fish in behavioral challenge experiments designed to test feeding (example Fig 2) and sheltering abilities. These results are not surprising as the physical and biological complexity of polyculture rearing systems would be expected to foster greater behavioral flexibility and better performance in challenge experiments.
Figure 2. Mean times in seconds (+SE) required to locate food in the dark by black sea bass cultured at four densities in monoculture and in polyculture with oysters.
Improvements in behavioral quality were not made at the expense of overall production. Survival of both species was similar in monoculture and polyculture systems. Growth of black seabass juveniles was similar in polyculture and monoculture, while, pigfish grew faster in polyculture than in monoculture (Fig 3).
Figure 3. Length weight relationship of pigfish (Orthopristis chrysoptera) cultured in four paired monoculture and polyculture rearing tanks.
A consistent difference in experiments for both fish stocks was production of a greater size range in polyculture than in monoculture systems. Greater size variability appears to reflect the expression of a greater range of behavioral phenotypes and can be viewed as a fundamental advantage in the culture of fish for release to the wild. Cohorts in the wild retain a wide range of size, presumably in response to temporal and spatial variability in natural conditions and in behavior. High spatial and temporal variability in the wild may allow survival of both shy (slow growing) and bold fish (fast growing). Some habitats and time periods may provide a selective advantage for aggressive fish while under different conditions shy fish survive better. Polyculture appears to allow expression of both shy and bold phenotypes while monoculture favors expression of aggressive behavior.
Behavioral superiority of polyculture fish appears to be rooted in differences in sensory abilities of fishes. Behavioral trials suggest that polyculture fish had more acute olfaction and better vision in low light conditions than monoculture fish. Direct evidence for differences in neural development between fish groups, such as difference in brain size or the extent of neural connection, have not been investigated and will be a priority in future studies. Future work should also investigate differences in the environment that the two systems provide. Preliminary investigations of oxygen dynamics in the two systems suggest significant differences between them in water quality (Fig. 4). Oxygen differences must be related to the inclusion of plants in polyculture systems and are likely to be reflected in other water quality parameters and ultimately important to fish health. An outbreak of a parasitic dinoflagellate in our grunt experiment provided evidence that grunts reared in polyculture had higher resistance than monoculture fish and we suspect that this was due in part to differences in water quality between the systems. The costs in labor and material for the two systems should also be considered. Our experience suggests that although materials and set up labor are greater for polyculture systems
Figure 4. Dissolved oxygen as percent saturation from two sets of paired tanks monitored for four day periods with a hydro lab water quality meter.
routine maintenance costs are greater for monoculture as it requires time consuming daily cleaning. Production of habitat forming species, such as oysters from the black seabass polyculture system could improve the economics of polyculture systems.
In summary, comparative studies detailed in this report provide evidence that polyculture represents a promising technique relative to conventional monoculture for the production of fish behaviorally suitable for stocking. This report supports future development of polyculture systems and more detailed investigation of their impact on physiological development and health of cultured fish, the physical dynamics of the culture environment and the economics of aquaculture.